annotate DOCS/tech/patches.txt @ 12645:3841ef14a481

name change
author diego
date Fri, 25 Jun 2004 16:43:34 +0000
parents 0d9dec871b83
children 4e0acc8d3622
Ignore whitespace changes - Everywhere: Within whitespace: At end of lines:
rev   line source
2121
95b8a1e7962d sending patches
arpi
parents:
diff changeset
1 Sending patches:
95b8a1e7962d sending patches
arpi
parents:
diff changeset
2 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
95b8a1e7962d sending patches
arpi
parents:
diff changeset
3
7645
534b9b6f6557 Some further explanations, dev-eng is now subscribers only.
diego
parents: 7153
diff changeset
4 Note: We know our rules place a burden on you, but rest assured that
534b9b6f6557 Some further explanations, dev-eng is now subscribers only.
diego
parents: 7153
diff changeset
5 maintaining a big and complex software project is even harder, so please
534b9b6f6557 Some further explanations, dev-eng is now subscribers only.
diego
parents: 7153
diff changeset
6 accept our rules. We cannot afford to spend our time fixing buggy, broken or
12218
52de6cbd0842 Patches should not be compressed.
diego
parents: 12106
diff changeset
7 outdated patches. The closer you follow our rules the higher is the probability
52de6cbd0842 Patches should not be compressed.
diego
parents: 12106
diff changeset
8 that your patch will be included.
7645
534b9b6f6557 Some further explanations, dev-eng is now subscribers only.
diego
parents: 7153
diff changeset
9
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
10 0. Do not send complete files. These need to be diffed by hand to see the
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
11 changes, which makes reviews harder and less likely to occur. Besides as
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
12 soon as one of the files changes, your version becomes harder to apply,
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
13 thus reducing its chances of being accepted.
11191
ed5969812ff3 Explain why sending complete files is a bad idea.
diego
parents: 10943
diff changeset
14
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
15 1. Always make patches for the CVS version. The README describes how to check
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
16 out CVS and daily CVS snapshots are available from our download page.
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
17 We do not accept patches for releases or outdated CVS versions.
2121
95b8a1e7962d sending patches
arpi
parents:
diff changeset
18
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
19 2. Make unified diffs ('diff -Naur' or 'cvs diff -u'). Unified diffs can be
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
20 applied easily with 'patch'. This is much harder with other diff types.
2121
95b8a1e7962d sending patches
arpi
parents:
diff changeset
21
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
22 3. Test the functionality of your patch. We'll *refuse* it if it breaks
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
23 something, even if it extends other features!
2121
95b8a1e7962d sending patches
arpi
parents:
diff changeset
24
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
25 4. Read your patch. We'll *refuse* it if it changes indentation of the
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
26 code or if it does tab/space conversion or other cosmetical changes!
2121
95b8a1e7962d sending patches
arpi
parents:
diff changeset
27
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
28 NOTE: If you alread wrote some code and did cosmetic changes, you can
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
29 use 'diff -uwbBE' to help you remove them. Don't forget to check the
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
30 patch to make sure diff didn't ignore some important change and remove
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
31 any remaining cosmetics!
12419
3a6e4fff88e3 Hint at diff options useful for avoiding cosmetic changes, patch by Reimar.
diego
parents: 12251
diff changeset
32
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
33 5. Comment parts that really need it (tricky side-effects etc).
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
34 Commenting trivial code not required. Comments must be English!
8556
ecff1745d189 Document things from the start.
diego
parents: 8432
diff changeset
35
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
36 6. If you implement new features, add or change command line switches or
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
37 modify the behavior of existing features, please do not forget to also
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
38 update the documentation. The documentation maintainers will assist you
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
39 in doing this. Updating the English documentation is enough. If you
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
40 speak several languages you are of course welcome to update some of the
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
41 translations as well.
12106
a79d9b3a83fd cosmetics
diego
parents: 11459
diff changeset
42
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
43 7. Send your patch to the mplayer-dev-eng mailing list as a base64-encoded
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
44 attachment (use gzip or bzip2 *only* if it's bigger than 80k or if you
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
45 know that your mailer messes up (reformats) text attachments) with the
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
46 subject line: '[PATCH] very short description of the patch'.
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
47 In the mail, describe in a few sentences what you change and why.
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
48 If you made independent changes, try to send them as separate patches.
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
49 The subject line is very important if you do not want your patch to get
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
50 lost in the noise. We need the uppercase [PATCH] to be able to search
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
51 for unapplied patches, so please use it.
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
52 You have to subscribe to mplayer-dev-eng since we blocked postings from
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
53 non-subscribers after spam problems and because patches get reviewed by
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
54 the developers on the list. We want you to be available for discussing
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
55 your code, you might be asked to make modifications before we accept it.
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
56 Don't worry, mplayer-dev-eng is not high traffic and you can subscribe
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
57 with the nomail option if you do not wish to receive all the mails.
2121
95b8a1e7962d sending patches
arpi
parents:
diff changeset
58
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
59 8. Give us a few days to react. We try to review patches as fast as possible,
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
60 but unfortunately we are constantly overloaded with work, be it MPlayer
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
61 related or from our day to day lives. If your patch seems to be ignored,
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
62 please resend it and mention that you got ignored. We are interested in
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
63 your work and will eventually either accept it or reject it with an
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
64 explanation what and why we disliked about your patch.
8432
7b6b7fb76965 small updates
diego
parents: 7645
diff changeset
65
12602
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
66 9. Do not immediately ask for CVS write access. If you contributed one or
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
67 more nice, acceptable patches and they need maintaining or you want to
0d9dec871b83 cosmetic reformatting (preparation for upcoming changes)
diego
parents: 12419
diff changeset
68 be an MPlayer developer, you'll get CVS write access.
11283
10e0ad4f21b6 _ vs - in option names
diego
parents: 11196
diff changeset
69
10e0ad4f21b6 _ vs - in option names
diego
parents: 11196
diff changeset
70 10. For consistency reasons all option names must use '-' instead of '_'.
11459
74e69aef2406 Contributors should also patch AUTHORS if they wish to appear there.
diego
parents: 11283
diff changeset
71
74e69aef2406 Contributors should also patch AUTHORS if they wish to appear there.
diego
parents: 11283
diff changeset
72 11. If you made a nontrivial contribution and wish to be mentioned in the
74e69aef2406 Contributors should also patch AUTHORS if they wish to appear there.
diego
parents: 11283
diff changeset
73 AUTHORS file, include that in your patch.
12106
a79d9b3a83fd cosmetics
diego
parents: 11459
diff changeset
74
12218
52de6cbd0842 Patches should not be compressed.
diego
parents: 12106
diff changeset
75 12. Do not compress your patch unless it is very large. It only makes handling
52de6cbd0842 Patches should not be compressed.
diego
parents: 12106
diff changeset
76 the patch more difficult.
52de6cbd0842 Patches should not be compressed.
diego
parents: 12106
diff changeset
77
2121
95b8a1e7962d sending patches
arpi
parents:
diff changeset
78 Thank you!