# HG changeset patch # User diego # Date 1067209696 0 # Node ID ff78d7ceecaa40c609987056b15b363147df8991 # Parent fffd200d81a70a020ee00e553729e16a05789a70 Dead links updated or removed, Joe Barr section rewritten taking into account his latest article. diff -r fffd200d81a7 -r ff78d7ceecaa DOCS/xml/en/users-vs-dev.xml --- a/DOCS/xml/en/users-vs-dev.xml Sun Oct 26 23:07:21 2003 +0000 +++ b/DOCS/xml/en/users-vs-dev.xml Sun Oct 26 23:08:16 2003 +0000 @@ -31,9 +31,8 @@ to GCC 2.96. Many developers around the world began having problems with GCC 2.96, and started recommending other compilers. Examples are MySQL, -avifile and -Wine. +avifile. Other interesting links are Linux kernel news flash about kernel 2.4.17 @@ -48,8 +47,6 @@ -You can read about the other side of the story -at this site. GCC 2.96 does not allow | (pipe) characters in assembler comments because it supports Intel as well as AT&T Syntax and the | character is a symbol in the Intel variant. The @@ -77,7 +74,7 @@ If you have problems with GCC 2.96, you can get 2.96-85 packages from the Red Hat ftp server, or just go for the 3.0.4 packages offered for version 7.2 and later. You can also -get gcc-3.2-10 packages +get gcc-3.2.3-11 packages (unofficial, but working fine) and you can install them along the gcc-2.96 you already have. MPlayer will detect it and use 3.2 instead of 2.96. If you do not want to or cannot use @@ -138,9 +135,9 @@ Another impediment to binary redistribution was compiletime optimizations for CPU architecture. MPlayer now supports -runtime CPU detection (specify the - option when compiling). It -is disabled by default because it implies a small speed sacrifice, it is +runtime CPU detection (pass the + to configure). +It is disabled by default because it implies a small speed sacrifice, but it is now possible to create binaries that run on different members of the Intel CPU family. @@ -157,8 +154,6 @@ mplayer-users about problems related to these closed-source drivers and their poor quality, instability and poor user and expert support. -Here is an example from the -nVidia Linux Forum. Many of these problems/issues keep appearing repeatedly. We have been contacted by nVidia lately, and they said these bugs do not exist, instability is caused by bad AGP chips, and they received no reports @@ -176,19 +171,16 @@ Joe Barr -Joe Barr became infamous by writing a less than favorable - -MPlayer review. -He found MPlayer hard to install, but then -again he is not very fond of -reading documentation. -He also concluded that the developers were unfriendly and the documentation -incomplete and insulting. You be the judge. -He went on to mention MPlayer negatively in his -10 Linux predictions for 2002. -In a followup -review of xine +Joe Barr became infamous in december 2001 by writing a less than favorable +MPlayer review called +MPlayer: The project from hell. +He found MPlayer hard to install, and concluded +that the developers were unfriendly and the documentation +incomplete and insulting. You be the judge of that. +He went on to mention Arpi negatively in his +10 Linux predictions for 2002. +In a followup review of xine called +A streaming media player for the rest of us he continued stirring up controversy. Ironically at the end of that article he quotes his exchange with Günter Bartsch, the original author of xine, that perfectly summarizes the whole situation: @@ -198,47 +190,35 @@ MPlayer and thought it was unfair, reminding me that it is a free software project. "If you don't like it," Bartsch said, "you're free not to use it." - - -He does not reply to our mails. His editor does not reply to our mails. -Here are some quotes from different people about Joe Barr, so you can form -your own opinion: - - - -Marc Rassbach has -something to say -about the man. +Almost two years later in october 2003 he wrote another review called +Mplayer revisited. +In it he came to the following conclusion: +He had the following to say about MPlayer:
-You may all remember the LinuxWorld 2000, when he claimed that Linus T said -that 'FreeBSD is just a handful of programmers'. Linus said NOTHING of the -sort. When Joe was called on this, his reaction was to call BSD supporters -assholes and jerks. +I would have to say that there have been improvements in the number of +features, in performance, and in documentation. It's still not the +easiest install in the world, especially for newbies, but it's a +little better than it used to be.
- - -A quote -from Robert Munro on the -mplayer-users -mailing list: +and -
- -He's interesting, but not good at avoiding, um... controversy. Joe Barr -used to be one of the regulars on Will Zachmann's Canopus forum on -Compuserve, years ago. He was an OS/2 advocate then (I was an OS/2 fan -too). - +
+But more importantly, I didn't notice any recent comments about user +abuse. I think I deserve some of the credit for that, even if I do say +so myself. Arpi and the rest of the project team must feel that way +too, because they have taken care to remember me in a special section +of the documentation included in the tarball. Like I said at the +start, some things haven't changed at all. +
- -He used to go over-the-top, flaming people, and I suspect he had some hard -times, then. He's mellowed some, judging by his columns recently. -Moderately subtle humor was not his mode in those earlier days, not at all. - -
+We could not have summarized our feelings towards Joe Barr better: +"It's still not the fairest or best researched article in the world, +but it's better than it used to be." Hopefully the next time around +we will meet each other's expectations. However, the credit for maturity +goes to our increasing age only, and maybe to being weary of flame wars.